Stay Out of the Basement Part 2

Stay Out of the Basement Part 2 is the name of the 13th episode of Goosebumps. It aired January 26, 1996

Plot
Margaret and Casey discover a man locked in a closet who says he is their real father and that the other is a plant.

Trivia

 * This episode was on the DVD, A Night in Terror Tower and the VHS, Stay Out of the Basement.